A recent Alabama court decision ruled the Corporate Transparency Act (CTA) unconstitutional, creating uncertainty for businesses nationwide. While the case may be appealed, here’s what boards of coops, condos, HOAs, and LLC members in New York, Connecticut and other states need to know right now.
On March 1, 2024, the Federal District Court in Alabama declared that the Act was unconstitutional. In the Judge’s words, the Act “exceeds the Constitution’s limits on the legislative branch and lacks a sufficient nexus to any enumerated power to be a necessary or proper means of achieving Congress’ policy goals.” As a result, the Judge found the Act to be unconstitutional because it exceeds the Constitution’s limits on Congress’ power. The Court, however, didn’t even reach a decision on whether it violates the First, Fourth, and Fifth Amendments. The Court permanently enjoined the government from enforcing the Act against the named plaintiffs and ordered a further hearing on the award of costs of litigation.
So, what is the rest of our Country supposed to do? We are going to have to wait and see what happens when, and if, the case is appealed to the Circuit court in Alabama and then possibly to the US Supreme Court. If we don’t hear more from the courts in New York, Connecticut and the other states, then compliance with the Act is still required. The case in Alabama only applies to the parties in that case and others in that District of Alabama right now arguably. Also the decision could be read narrowly, only applying the small businesses that are a part of the trade organization in Alabama that was involved in that lawsuit. Thus, most of the corporate entities that are covered by the Act, must still comply with the Act.
Next Steps:
- Stay Informed: Monitor legal developments regarding the CTA’s status.
- Review Your Status: Determine if your organization falls under the CTA’s reporting requirements.
- Consult Counsel: If unsure about your obligations, or considering a potential challenge, seek legal advice.
Here is an Article that we previously published on the CTA. Stay tuned for more.
